ELECTRIFICATION OF THE SUBURBAN NETWORK OF THE SRI LANKA RAILWAY ECONOMIC STUDY Gallage Maheel Prasanta A dissertation submitted in the partial fulfillment of the requirements For the degree of Master of Engineering in Electrical Engineering Department of Electrical Engineering University of Moratuwa Sri Lanka December 2002 78480 ABSTRACT Rapidly increasing congestion of traffic in urban and suburban roads raises the necessity of better and quicker railway service urgently. Electrified railway system is a better solution for that. The prime objective of this electrification economic study is to determine Whether electrical operation of the Sri Lanka suburban railway is economically viable and more advantageous than that of the existing diesel operation system with further improvement. According to present railway passenger flow , geographical data of railway tracks and other railway statistics and population of Sri Lanka, the network of suburban railway stations Kalutara North- Colombo-;· Polgahawela, Colombo - Homagama and Ragama Negombo (Colombo International Airport ) was selected as high passenger density area. In the selected suburban area, railway and road passenger flow was studied by us in g train formation , railway time table , tickets issued at railway stations (daily and season tickets) and survey details of major railway stations and bus stand s. According to above data peak hour and daily pass enger flow for one day was calculated. Some technical detail s were selected as to be compatible with the existing system with few modifications, to retain the ability of continued operation o f the present diesel locomotives. Other technical data was selected by studying established electrification systems in other countries. Finally, total electrical multiple unit s, clearance specifications , specific energy consumption, power requirement , power generation and distribution were determined. Total cost of electrification system and improved existing diesel system was calculated separately and compared . Electrification system was found to be economically viable for 3 0 years and the cost was less than that of the improved existing diesel system. AKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author wishes to express his deep gratitude to Prof L. Lucas, head of the Electrical Department of University of Moratuwa and Dr H.J.C. Peiris, course coordinator and supervisor of this project for guidance and encouragement given during the period of this project. Author also wishes to extend his sincere thanks to Dr. Naleen Wikramarachchi , the present course coordinator. The author acknowledges the corporation given by the stationmasters and their staff of the railway stations in the selected suburban areas during the survey period. The author gratefully appreciates the Department of Sri;Lanka Railway for the financial assistance given and the University of Moratuwa for the facilities provided during the study period. Finally, I wish to thank my wife Sujeeva for her patience, understanding and also assistance given to me to complete this thesis . ... • - 11 Fig. l.l Fig. A2.1 Fig A2.2 Fig A2.3 Fig A3. 1 Fig. A4. 1 Fig. B.l Fig. B.2 Fig. 8 .3 Fig. B.4 Fig. B.5 Fig. B.6 Fig. B.7 LIST OF FIGURES Sri Lanka Railway Network Typical speed/time curve for electric trains operating on passenger services Speed/time curve for suburban service Simplified (trapezoidal shape) Speed /Time curve Percentage gradient Mechanism of train movement Diesel Multiple Unit Electric M ultiple Unit General arrangement of four car nonnal E .M.U. General arrangement of four car special E.M.U. 25kv 50Hz simple feed catenary system Types of catenary Traction overhead equipment ... - ill .1 Page No 03 62 63 64 67 68 78 78 79 83 87 89 90 - LIST OF TABLES Page No Table 1.1 Description of rail routes 04 Table 3.1 Proposed track system 14 Table 3.2 Expected peak hour one direction passenger flow 15 (suburban area) Table 3.3 Expected daily one direction passenger flow 16 (suburban area) Table 3.4 Expected peak hour one direction passenger flow 16 (from non-suburban area) I Table 3.5 Expected daily one direction passenger flow 16 (from non-suburban area) Table 4.1 Requirements of normal E.M.U.s 19 Table 5.1 Power supply arrangement 35 Table 5.2 Power stations capacity 38 Table 6.1 Cost of energy per day 39 Table 7.1 Total normal E. M. U. passenger kilometres 46 Table 7.2 Total special E.M.U. passenger kilometres 46 Table 8.1 Cash flow analysis of the electrification project 50 Table 8.2 Cash flow analysis of the improved diesel project 51 Table A1.1 Present rail passeng<;.r traffic flow (Colombo Fort- Kalutara South suburban service) 57 Table Al.2 Present rail passenger traffic flow (Colombo Fort- Polgahawela suburban service) 58 Table Al.3 Present rail passenger traffic flow (Colombo Fort - Homagama suburban service) 59 Table Al.4 Present rail passenger traffic flow (Colombo Fort- Negombo suburban service) 60 Table A1.5 Present rail passenger traffic flow (from non-suburban area) 61 Table Al.6 Road passenger traffic flow 61 Table A8.1 Basis for lateral displacements (locomotives) ·- 75 Table A8.2 Basis for lateral displacements (multiple unit cars) 75 Table A8.3 Altitude compensation 75 Table A8.4 Air clearances 76 Table A8.5 Supper elevation allowance 76 IV TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT AKNOWLEDGEMENTS LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF TABLES TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1 1.0 Introduction 1 .1 Electric Traction 1.2 Sri Lanka Railway 1.3 Electrification Studies in Sri Lanka 1.4 Proposed Project CHAPTER 2 2.0 Objectives and Methodology 2.1 General 2.2 Traffic 2.3 Capital Equipment Cost 2.4 Annual Operating Expe_Dses 2.5 Maintenance of Way Changes 2.6 Intangible Benefits and Liabilities CHAPTER 3 ... 3.0 Proposed Operating System of Suburban Area 3.1 Electrification Area 3.2 Rail Track System And Operating System 3.3 Passenger Flow CHAPTER4 4.0 Electrical Multiple Units 4.1 Requirements ofNorrnal E.M.U.s 4.2 Requirements of Special E.M.U.s 4.3 Technical Details 4.4 Specific Energy Consumption 4. 5 Energy Returned to the Line v I ~ Page No I II III IV v 01 01 02 04 05 06 06 07 08 10 12 12 13 13 14 15 17 18 20 21 25 27 CHAPTER 5 5. 0 Railroad Electrification System 5.1 Power Distribution 5.2 Electrical Clearances 5.3 Catenary System 5.4 Power Stations and Substations CHAPTER 6 6.0 Cost of the Project 6.1 Electrical Multiple Unit System 6.2 Improved Diesel Multiple Unit System CHAPTER 7 7.0 Cost of the Project 7.1 Electrical Multiple Unit System 7.2 Improved Diesel Multiple Unit System CHAPTERS 8.0 Project Evaluation CHAPTER9 9. 0 Discussion CHAPTER 10 10.0 Conclusion CHAPTER 11 11 .0 References APPENDIX - A Annexes APPENDIX-B Diagrams and Pictures ... - Yl j - 29 29 30 32 34 39 39 43 46 46 48 49 52 54 55 56 77