C O M M U N I T Y S P A C E S I N U R B A N L O W - I N C O M E R E S I D E N T I A L E N V I R O N M E N T S I N S R I L A N K A A N D I T S A P P L I C A B I L I T Y T O H I G H - D E N S I T Y L I V I N G A dissertation presented to the Faculty of Architecture University of Moratuwa For the Final Examination in M. Sc. Architecture J. D. Wijethi lake Faculty of Architecture University of Moratuwa Sri Lanka " May, 2000 074087 University of Moratuwa 7 4 0 8 7 74087 T H A B S T R A C T From the history of civilization community spaces have been playing an important role in establishing the ' sense of community ' within residential neighbourhoods. How ever, with urbanization communal life has become a very compl icated, decreasing its importance. Due to the lack of proper environment for rich communal life, people have to live within a situation where the people and the places are unknown and instances were the information is unreliable. This has led people to live individually. Within such a situation it has become a chal lenge to achieve communi ty cohesion. Nevertheless, the community experts have understood the importance of communi ty spaces as objects of creating healthy interaction among people of the community and therefore generating community cohesion. Their opinion is to use architecture to achieve this. It has been revealed that high - density residential areas are the most crucial in that problem. Therefore this study is basically aimed at exploring the strategies that have been adopted to create healthy social interaction and identifying the contribution of built environment in terms of the design of community spaces. The study will specifically examine the contention that such community spaces are used variously by the inhabitants of the residences and that certain strategies used in these spaces are more conducive the interaction than others. Therefore, the first stage of this study traces the value of urban public spaces as community spaces. The second part examines the role communi ty spaces play within residential communit ies. At this the vitality of communal life as a key social binder and the forces shaping the communal life is discussed. Finally the study consider about the importance of community spaces within low-income residential environments for their well - being. It identifies how the mechanisms of social interaction and generating a sense of community together could promote an architecture, which could uplift the neighbourly att i tudes of people. The absence of above mechanisms had resulted number of problems in high-density areas. Lack of 'sense of community ' is one of those. The study reveals the applicability of community spaces as a solution for that problem. From the total study, it tries to explain the importance of the built - environment generating social interaction. Hence gives a clear knowledge of its accepted mores, and predictable guidelines for behaviour, an essential f ramework for social stability. So that, architects should understand the importance of built envi ronment in terms of organization of space as a vehicle of behaviour for sense of control and collective coherent among the people, in creating a neighbourhood. Therefore it explains the applicability of community spaces for the creation of meaningful and habitable environments in high - density-housing schemes, to create sense of community within those neighbourhoods. ii A C K N O W L E D M E N T Many people helped me to make this dissertation a reality. It is to them that I humbly pay tribute Archt. Vidura Sri Nammuni , senior lecturer, Dept. of Architecture for the inspiring discussions, advice and comments, the consent encouragement f rom the beginning and above all for believing in its worth. Dr L.S.R. Perera, Archt. D.P Chandrasekara, Senior Lecturers, Dept of Architecture, for their invaluable advises. Prasanna, Wasana, Champika, Manjula, Chandrasir i , Basnayake and Mahagama for all the assistance offered and especially for their kind encouragements when the going was rough. Nimali, for spending her valuable t ime, uncomplaingly, in making typescript. t My dear parents and brothers and sisters, for their sincere consent and encouragement given when I was morally down and throughout my dissertat ion. Finally, to each and everyone, mentioned and unmentioned here, thank you once again for being with me, sparing your valuable t ime, on my behalf in making study a possibility. CONTENTS FIRST CHAPTER USE OF URBAN PUBLIC SPACE AS COMMUNITY SPACES 1.1 Definition of urban public space 7 1.2 Manifestation of urban public spaces 9 1.2.1. Unplanned development 9 1.2.2. Planned development 11 1.3 Typology of urban public spaces and observable patterns 12 1.3.1 Recreation oriented urban public spaces 14 1.3.2 Commercial oriented urban public spaces 17 1.3.3 Transport oriented urban public spaces 19 1.3.4 Residential oriented urban public spaces 19 1.3.5 Religious oriented urban public spaces 20 1.4 Signif icance of urban public spaces as community spaces. 21 SECOND CHAPTER COMMUNITY SPACES IN RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENTS 2.1 Definition to the community space 24 2.2 Nature of communal life within a residential community space 25 2.3 Nature of contacts within a residential community space 26 2.4 Importance of communal life as a key social binder 29 2.5 Forces shaping the communal life 34 2 .5 .1 . Social forces 35 2.5.2. Physical forces 36 2.6 Communi ty spaces as a reflection of communal life within residential environments. 38 2 .70bservab le patterns of residential community spaces Page i iii v i 1 I V ABSTRACT A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T CONTENTS LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS INTRODUCTION THIRD CHAPTER COMMUNITY SPACES IN URBAN LOW-INCOME RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENTS AND ITS USAGE 3.1 Communi ty spaces in urban low-income Residential Environments 45 3.1.1 Urban low-income residential environments 45 3.1.2 Types and nature of community spaces within urban low-income residential environments 46 3.1.3 Mechanisms of enhancing social interactions in strengthening the ' sense of communi ty ' 46 3.1.3.1 Mechanisms of creating social interaction within a communi ty space 47 3.1.3.2 Creation of 'sense of community ' within the neighbourhood 59 3.1.4 Use of the " sense of community " for the well being of residential communit ies 62 3.1.5 Case studies 64 a.) Panchikawatta low-income residential community 65 b.) Nawagampura low-income residential community 75 3.2 Applicabil i ty of community spaces in high-density living. 83 3.2.1 Definition to high-density living 83 3.2.2 Factors leading high-density living 84 3.2.3 Problems of high-density living 87 3.2.4 Applicabil i ty of community spaces as solution for that. 90 3.3 Concluding remarks 91 CONCLUSION 96 BIBLIOGRAPHY 100 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Page Fig. 1 Urban public space - where the city dweller can move freely and use these spaces for communicat ion, social interaction and other urban activities 8 Fig. 2 Urban public space with periodic festivities 8 Fig. 3 Residential communi ty space 8 Fig. 4 Complex regional plaza 9 Fig. 5 Negat ive urban space 9 Fig. 6 Urban public space- through appropriat ion- little space in front of a building as a public space 10 Fig. 7 Urban public space- by repeated use- street as a play space for chi ldren 10 Fig. 8 Urban public space- by connecting people because of an attraction- "Pil lewa Bo Samindu' 11 Fig. 9 Urban public space- through deliberate planning 11 Fig.10 Accidental urban public space 12 Fig. 11 Three main geometr ical patterns of urban public spaces. Squares, tr iangles, circles 13 Fig. 12 Classif ication of urban public spaces by taking in to account the image of a city 13 Fig. 13 Urban public space along water ways- Galle face 15 Fig.14 Central park-V iharamahadev i Park 15 Fig. 15 Neighborhood parks -15 a - Privately developed neighborhood parks 15 b - Publicly developed neighborhood parks 16 Fig.16 Monumental space 17 Fig. 17 Market Street 18 Fig. 18 Market square 18 Fig. 19 Combinat ion of Market Square and street 18 Fig.20 Transport oriented urban public space 19 Fig. 21 Religious oriented urban public space 20 Fig.22 Residential oriented urban public space 21 Fig.23 Children's play ground under parents' observation 22 Fig.24 Street as a community space 22 Fig.25 Positive interaction 27 Fig 26 Act ive contacts 27 Fig.27 Passive contacts 28 Fig.28 What is needed is a framework which is just enough def ined. So that people naturally tend to stop there 30 Fig.29 Big communi ty spaces- at these situations people turn towards their own concerns without giving much consideration to others 31 Fig.30 Chi ldhood spaces 34 Fig.31 Socio-cultural forces affecting on communal life 35 Fig.32 Location- affecting on communal life 37 Fig.33 Recreation oriented community space- Large playground 41 Fig.34 Commercia l oriented community spaces - 34 a -"Pola" 42 vi - 34 b - Individual boutique Fig. 35 Religious oriented community spaces 43 Fig. 36 Public water tap as a community space 43 Fig. 37 Visual contact with different spaces can enhance its sense of security 48 Fig. 39 Communi ty spaces in low-income residential environments- enhancing visual connect ions 48 Fig. 40 Lay-out - physical comfort - court yard of a cluster of houses 50 Fig. 41 The arrangement of seating, with the physical and psychological comfort of a wider user category is essential for creating convenience 50 Fig. 42 Safety f rom vehicular traffic also very important in creating attraction to spaces such as streets, which are used as community spaces 51 Fig. 43 Urban dweller frequently seek settings for relaxation in a quiet relaxing atmosphere 52 Fig. 44 Communi ty participation programs 52 Fig. 45 Physical access 53 Fig. 46 Symbol ic access 53 Fig. 47 Diversity, variety and intimacy 54 Fig. 50 Communi ty spaces may have physical features that substitute the feel ings of natural elements for creating interest 55 Fig. 51 Hierarchy of public spaces 57 Fig. 52 Special features such as trees- create connections between people 58 Fig. 53 Mechanisms of street enclosure a n d . . . 60 Fig. 54 Territoriality is important for people to feel more able to extend their control over their immediate surrounding 61 Fig. 55 Communi ty spaces in traditional societies 63 Fig. 56 The maintenance of human scale and diversity along the facades has created interesting and lively atmosphere along the road 67 Fig 57 Commercia l establ ishments such as wayside boutiques, small-scale shops, street vendors increase the relative safety of the street 68 Fig. 58 Due to the incorporation of public spaces adjoining to the commercial areas, safety is enhanced 68 Fig. 59 Ways ide taps forms a place for the public as a meeting space 69 Fig. 60 The small play ground open at one end 69 Fig. 61 Opportunity of visual contacts through the al leyways 70 Fig. 62 Lay out - court yard to cluster of houses 70 Fig. 63 These al leyways are used by children as play spaces 71 Fig. 64 Access ways between housing units, which are beginning from Main Street. This could achieve demarcat ion of semi-public and semi-private areas 72 Fig. 65 Variety and the diversity of the built environment 73 Fig. 66 "Sense of spaciousness" within compacted buildings 74 Fig. 67 "Sense of openness" encourages their participation Fig. 68 Diversity and intimacy creating a visual interest for participation 77 Fig. 69 Street taps as community spaces 77 Fig. 70 Intimacy and intricacy generating intimate encounters 78 Fig. 71 Transit ional spaces ^ = = ^ s = ^ 79 Fig. 72 Communa l activities discourage the through traffic 79 Fig. 73 Common taps within courtyards of clusters create more privatized environments 80 Fig. 74 Lay out- courtyard of cluster of houses 80 Fig. 75 Comfortable environment for gathering 81 Fig. 76 Al though a community space with a large play ground is provided, most of the communal activities are happening at informal open spaces 82 Fig. 77 High-density development due to rapid urbanization 83 Fig. 78 High-density living in high-rise built environments has created more crucial problems, which resulted the isolated, anonymous and helpless group of community 87 Fig. 79 Presence of natural elements at high-density or at high-rise situations, create special meanings for people 91 Viii